When choosing a home for rent or purchase, you have many options available in the market. You will find standalone buildings and gated communities, and the ample choices will confuse you. However, there is a huge difference between standalone buildings and gated societies! Each comes with its advantages and disadvantages that widely depend on your lifestyle, preferences, and budget. While the standalone buildings are independent structures, the gated residential buildings offer a secure environment. To help you make the right decision, here is a complete guide to where you should choose standalone alone buildings or gated residential complexes.
What is a Standalone Building?
A standalone building is an independent structure not attached to any other building. It offers complete autonomy and self-sufficiency. Occupants of standalone buildings feel a sense of privacy, as there are no common areas or shared walls with neighbouring properties. One of the main features of a standalone building is greater flexibility in terms of customisation and usage.
If you buy a standalone building, you can modify the layout and design according to their preferences. The buildings have private entrances and separate utility connections, giving you a sense of ownership and exclusivity. Another reason for people choosing standalone buildings is affordable maintenance costs.
Also Read: 7 Most Posh Localities In Bangalore To Consider In 2024
What is a Gated Community?
A gated community is a residential area with restricted entry for residents and guests. It usually consists of different housing types, such as villas or apartment complexes. Gated communities are designed to offer their inhabitants a sense of exclusivity and security.
One key factor of gated communities is their emphasis on security. They feature 24/7 surveillance, monitored entrances and exits, and security personnel. The enhanced security can bring peace of mind, making gated communities appealing to families looking for a safer environment.
Also Read: Top 7 Posh Areas In Hyderabad & Gated Communities To Know
Standalone Buildings vs. Gated Communities: Which One Should You Choose?
There are many factors to consider when choosing between gated communities and standalone houses. Budget, security, lifestyle preferences, and amenities are a few factors that help you choose between standalone houses and gated communities in India. Below, we share a glimpse of standalone homes vs gated societies.
| Feature | Standalone Buildings | Gated Communities |
| Privacy | Higher level of privacy due to no shared walls or common areas. | Less privacy as homes are closer together but often have controlled access. |
| Security | May have security concerns; homeowners need to arrange their own security measures. | Enhanced security with guards, CCTV, and controlled access points. |
| Cost | Generally, it is more affordable with lower initial purchase and maintenance costs. | Higher costs (10%-40% more) due to amenities and security features. |
| Amenities | Limited or no shared amenities; relies on individual arrangements for facilities. | Access to various amenities like pools, gyms, and parks, enhancing lifestyle quality. |
| Customisation | Greater freedom to modify and customise the property as desired. | Restrictions on modifications due to community rules and regulations. |
| Maintenance Responsibility | Homeowners are fully responsible for maintenance and repairs. | Maintenance is often managed by the community, reducing individual burdens. |
| Community Interaction | Limited social interaction; may feel isolated without a sense of community. | Strong sense of community with opportunities for social activities and interactions. |
Also Read: Top 7 Posh Localities in Delhi For Renting & Buying In 2024
Advantages of Choosing Standalone Buildings Near You
Standalone buildings offer excellent benefits that make them an appealing choice for residential and commercial purposes. Here are some of the key advantages:
1. Cost-effective Maintenance
With fewer residents, maintenance and management of facilities are easier and more cost-effective in standalone houses. This leads to low upkeep costs and less frequent repairs than bigger residential complexes.
2. Enhanced Privacy
Standalone buildings offer increased privacy compared to apartments or condos. With no shared spaces, you can enjoy your home without the disturbances of multi-unit dwellings.
3. Full Control and Autonomy
Owing a standalone house means having total control over the property. There are no common areas or shared walls, providing greater autonomy in managing the space without interference from neighbours or tenants.
Also Read: 11 Cleanest Cities In India In 2024 You Need To Know [Ranked]
Disadvantages of Choosing Standalone Houses
While standalone buildings offer many advantages, they come with limitations. Before you start looking up a standalone building near you, you should also consider these disadvantages.
1. Security Concerns
Security is a critical issue for standalone houses, which do not have comprehensive security measures like gated communities. Some standalone buildings might have CCTVs, but most lack the advanced system found in gated communities.
2. Parking Challenges
Parking can be an issue for standalone houses, especially when your friends are visiting. Limited space often leads to difficulty finding adequate parking for residents and guests, which can be particularly frustrating in busy environments.
3. Limited Amenities
Standalone houses lack essential amenities, including communal spaces, gyms, and swimming pools that you can usually find in a gated society. The absence of amenities can lead to a lifestyle you might not be satisfied with.
Also Read: 5 Best Places To Live In Gurgaon: Price Trends In 2024
Advantages of Choosing Gated Communities Near You
Gated societies are popular among many homeowners, and various homeowners choose to live in gated societies over standalone buildings.
1. Enhanced Security
One of the top benefits of living in a gated community is better security. The communities usually have controlled access points that security personnel monitor. This significantly reduces the risk of unauthorised entry and crime. There are usually surveillance cameras to ensure safety and peace of mind.
2. Better Property Values
Properties within gated residential complexes often appreciate at a quicker rate than those in non-gated areas, owing to desirable features such as security and amenities. This leads to a greater long-term investment value for homebuyers.
3. Increased Privacy
Gated societies offer a better value of privacy compared to traditional neighbourhoods. With limited access for outsiders, residents can enjoy a more peaceful environment. This will allow you to carry out daily activities without any disruptions. If you are someone who finds privacy appealing, you can expect a tranquil living environment inside.
Disadvantages of Choosing Gated Residential Complexes
Gated communities offer an array of different benefits, but you should consider the limitations you might face. Below are the common disadvantages of living in gated communities:
1. Higher Costs
Living in a gated society comes with a higher property price as you have to pay additional homeowners’ association fees. The fees cover the maintenance of shared amenities and security services, which can increase over time.
2. Strict Rules and Regulations
Gated communities usually enforce strict rules and regulations regarding the property’s appearance and residents’ behaviours. These regulations may restrict personal freedoms like home extensions, landscape choices, and noise levels. While the rules focus on community standards, many residents can feel overly protective.
Also Read: Top 7 Residential Areas In Mumbai: Affordable To Posh Areas
Standalone Building vs. Gated Societies: Price Differences
Generally, standalone buildings are more affordable than gated communities, and prices are usually 10%-40% lower than standalone buildings. In Gurgaon, the average cost for a standalone apartment is ₹10,000 to ₹15,000 per square foot, based on the location. The gated communities start at ₹12,000 per square foot and can go up to ₹25,000 or more. In Delhi, the standalone buildings are more affordable compared to gated communities – the standalone apartments start at ₹8,000 to ₹12,000 per square foot, and gated societies range between ₹10,000 and over ₹20,000.
| City | Standalone Building Price (₹ per sq. ft.) | Gated Community Price (₹ per sq. ft.) | Rental Price (Standalone) | Rental Price (Gated Community) |
| Gurgaon | ₹10,000 – ₹15,000 | ₹12,000 – ₹25,000 | ₹45,000 (2,200 sq ft) | ₹75,000 (2,200 sq ft) |
| Delhi | ₹8,000 – ₹12,000 | ₹10,000 – ₹20,000 | Varies widely | Varies widely |
| Bangalore | ₹5,500 – ₹10,500 | ₹8,500 – ₹18,000 | Varies widely | Varies widely |
| Mumbai | ₹12,000 – ₹20,000 | ₹15,000 – ₹30,000 | Varies widely | Varies widely |
| Kolkata | ₹4,500 – ₹8,500 | ₹6,500 – ₹15,000 | Varies widely | Varies widely |
| Hyderabad | ₹6,000 – ₹10,000 | ₹8,000 – ₹16,000 | Varies widely | Varies widely |
Meanwhile, standalone buildings are a more budget-friendly option, with lower purchase and rental costs. You should consider your priorities and needs—do you want enhanced security? Or are you on a strict budget? Whether you value affordability or are willing to invest more, you should consider the additional features. If you are new to the city and want to furnish your place at an affordable price, check out RentoMojo!
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Is a gated community worth it?
Living in a gated community can be worth it for those who prioritise security, privacy, and community amenities, but it may not be suitable for everyone due to higher costs and restrictions on personal freedom.
2. What is the largest gated community in India?
The largest gated community in India is Vasavi Ananda Nilayam, located in Hyderabad. It covers an area of 8.5 million square feet and consists of 3,576 units across 11 towers.
3. What is the difference between gated and non-gated communities?
A gated community is a residential area with controlled access and enhanced security features, while a non-gated community lacks these restrictions, offering more open access and typically lower prices but potentially less security and amenities.
4. Is it good to buy a flat in a standalone building?
Buying a flat in a standalone building can be a good choice for those seeking affordability and greater control over their living space. However, it may have drawbacks, such as limited security and amenities compared to gated communities.
5. Which are the best gated buildings in Bangalore?
Some of the best gated communities in Bangalore include Sunny Brooks Community in Sarjapur, Prestige Shantiniketan in Whitefield, DSR Elite in Mahadevapura, SNN Clermont in Hebbal, and Sattva Magnificia on Old Madras Road, all offering a range of luxurious amenities and excellent connectivity.
